Gray Hairstreak (Strymon melinus)
Small, slate-grey and almost impossible to avoid, the gray hairstreak is the most widespread hairstreak in North America and probably the least fussy butterfly on the continent — its caterpillars have been recorded on plants from dozens of unrelated families. Perched on a flower it saws its hindwings back and forth, waving a pair of thread-thin tails beside a red-and-black spot so that the back end of the butterfly looks convincingly like its head.

In this guide
Description and identification
The gray hairstreak belongs to the gossamer-winged butterflies, Lycaenidae, the family that also holds the blues, coppers and elfins. Within it, the hairstreaks are the group that carries hair-fine tails on the hindwing, and Strymon melinus is by some distance the most common and most widely distributed of them in North America. It is also the one most likely to turn up in a vegetable patch or on a city verge.
Adult butterfly
- Wingspan: 0.9–1.4 in (22–35 mm) — a small butterfly, roughly the size of a thumbnail with the wings folded.
- Upperside: uniform slate grey to blue-grey, darkest in fresh spring individuals, with a bright red-orange spot capped with black near the tail on each hindwing. The upperside is only seen in flight or when the butterfly briefly basks, because perched hairstreaks nearly always keep their wings closed.
- Underside: the surface you will actually be looking at. It is plain grey — dark and slaty in the spring brood, noticeably paler in summer — crossed by a single narrow postmedian line that is white and black and bordered on the inner side with orange. Near the tail sit one large red-orange spot with a black cap and a smaller black spot.
- Tails: each hindwing carries one long white-tipped tail and usually a much shorter second one beside it.
- Body: grey, fairly stout for such a small butterfly, with black-and-white banded antennae tipped in orange.
- Sexes: very similar. Females average slightly paler and a little shorter in the body; males have a small oval patch of scent scales on the leading edge of the forewing upperside, visible only in the hand. Sexing this species in the field is unreliable.
How to identify a gray hairstreak in the field
Look for a small grey butterfly perched head-down on a flower head in an open, weedy, sunny place, with the wings shut and the hindwings sliding back and forth against each other. That sawing motion, which makes the tails twitch like antennae, is characteristic of hairstreaks and immediately separates them from blues. Then check the underside: plain grey with one clean orange-edged white line, plus a red spot by the tail, is the gray hairstreak. A butterfly with a broad red-orange band below is the red-banded hairstreak; a green one is the juniper hairstreak; a tiny tailed butterfly that is blue rather than grey underneath is the eastern tailed-blue.

Life cycle: egg, caterpillar, chrysalis and adult



There are two generations a year in the north, three or four in the south, and in Florida, south Texas and coastal southern California the butterfly breeds almost continuously. A generation takes about four to six weeks in warm weather.
Eggs
The female lays her eggs singly on the flower buds and young flowers of the host plant rather than on the leaves — a sensible choice, because the caterpillar's first food is the flower itself. Each egg is a flattened pale green to whitish disc about 0.6 mm across, and under magnification the surface is a beautiful pitted honeycomb that looks like a miniature sea urchin. Eggs hatch in four to eight days, and a single weedy field can hold eggs on clover, mallow and knotweed at the same time.
Caterpillar
The caterpillar is shaped like a woodlouse: flattened, oval and slug-like, with the head tucked out of sight beneath the body and a covering of very short downy hairs. Colour is remarkably variable and often matches whatever the larva is eating — green, yellow-green, pink, rose or pale brown, usually with a darker line along the back and faint oblique dashes along the sides. It grows to about 0.7 in (18 mm). Young larvae bore into buds, flowers, seed pods and fruits and only take leaves as they get older, and it is this boring habit that gives the species its two agricultural names, cotton square borer and bean lycaenid.
Like many lycaenid larvae, the gray hairstreak caterpillar has a small gland on its back that produces a sugary secretion. Ants drink it and, in exchange, patrol the caterpillar and drive off parasitic wasps and flies. The relationship is optional on both sides, but caterpillars with an ant escort survive noticeably better.
Chrysalis
The full-grown larva usually leaves the plant and pupates in leaf litter, in a crevice or at the base of a stem, held in place by a silk pad and a fine silk girdle. The chrysalis is about 0.4 in (10 mm) long, plump and rounded like a shelled peanut, mid to dark brown, speckled with darker flecks and covered in a short velvety pile that helps it disappear into soil and dead leaves. Summer pupae open in seven to ten days; the last generation of the year overwinters as a chrysalis and emerges the following spring.
Adult butterfly
Adults live roughly two to four weeks. They are on the wing from about February in the far south, from May in the north, and into October or November in warmer states, with each brood overlapping the next so that fresh and worn individuals fly together for much of the season.
Where the gray hairstreak lives
The gray hairstreak has one of the largest ranges of any North American butterfly. It occurs from southern British Columbia, the prairie provinces, Ontario, Quebec and the Maritimes south through every one of the lower 48 states, right through Texas and Mexico and Central America, and on into Colombia and Venezuela. Very few butterflies span that much latitude, and fewer still are common throughout.
It is a butterfly of open, sunny, disturbed ground — the opposite of a forest specialist. Weedy fields, roadsides, railway banks, vacant lots, pastures, prairie, gardens, farmland, orchard edges, streambanks and open woodland all suit it, and it climbs to around 8,000 ft (2,400 m) in the mountains of the West. Dense shade is the one habitat it avoids. Because its caterpillars accept so many plants and its preferred habitats are the ones human activity creates, the gray hairstreak has probably gained ground over the last century, and it is genuinely at home in a city.
Host plants and diet
Caterpillar host plants. This is the gray hairstreak's defining trait: it is one of the most polyphagous butterflies in North America, recorded from plants in dozens of families. The two that matter most are the pea family, Fabaceae — beans, peas, clovers, alfalfa, lespedeza, tick trefoil, lupine and vetch — and the mallow family, Malvaceae, above all cotton, hibiscus, hollyhock and the wild mallows. Beyond those it uses knotweeds, mints, strawberry, hawthorn, oak, hops, corn, okra and blueberry, choosing whatever is in bud locally. Because larvae feed inside cotton flower buds, or "squares", and inside bean pods, the species is an occasional minor crop pest, though it rarely reaches damaging numbers. Our guide to butterfly host plants explains why most butterflies are far more restricted than this.
Adult diet. Adults have short tongues and feed at small, shallow, densely packed flowers: dogbane, common and swamp milkweed, white and yellow sweet clover, mints, goldenrod, winter cress, tickseed sunflower, mountain mint and garden herbs in flower. They also take moisture and minerals from damp soil. A stand of flowering mint or milkweed in a weedy corner is the most reliable place to find them.

Behavior: the false head, perching and flight
The false head. The rear corner of a gray hairstreak's hindwing is built to look like the front end of a butterfly. Two hair-thin white-tipped tails stand in for antennae, an orange-and-black spot stands in for an eye, and the lines on the underside converge on the spot exactly as real wing veins converge on a real head. When the butterfly lands it swivels to face downwards and then rubs its hindwings alternately back and forth, so the fake antennae move while the real ones are held still. A bird or a jumping spider striking at the apparent head takes a bite out of expendable wing margin, and the butterfly escapes. Individuals with a neat triangular notch out of both hindwings and no tails left are extremely common, and each one is a survivor.
Perching males. Males do not patrol. Through the afternoon they take up station on the top of a shrub, a tall weed or a fence line — often on a rise or hilltop — and sit with the wings closed, darting out at any passing insect and returning to the same twig. Females fly through these areas and mating follows.
Flight. The flight is fast, low and distinctly erratic, a rapid flickering zigzag close to the vegetation that is genuinely hard to follow with the eye. They rarely fly far in one go and usually drop back onto a flower within a few yards. Compared with a summer azure drifting along a woodland edge, the hairstreak looks as though it is in a hurry.
Season and broods. Two broods fly in the northern states and southern Canada, roughly May to June and July to September. Three or four broods are normal in the south, and in Florida, south Texas and southern California adults can be found in almost any month. The species does not migrate.

Similar butterflies and how to tell them apart
| Species | Looks like | How to separate it from the gray hairstreak |
|---|---|---|
| Red-banded hairstreak, Calycopis cecrops | Small grey tailed hairstreak of the same weedy places | The postmedian line is a wide red-orange band, not a thin white line with an orange edge; upperside shows blue on the hindwing; smaller |
| Banded hairstreak, Satyrium calanus | Grey-brown hairstreak with tails | Underside brown, the postmedian line broken into offset white-edged dashes; no bright orange on the upperside; flies near oaks and hickories in midsummer only |
| Juniper hairstreak, Callophrys gryneus | Small tailed hairstreak | Underside green with a white line; always found near red cedar or juniper |
| Great purple hairstreak, Atlides halesus | Dark hairstreak with long tails | Much bigger, brilliant iridescent blue above, with a red-orange abdomen and red spots at the wing bases; associated with mistletoe |
| Eastern tailed-blue, Cupido comyntas | Tiny butterfly with hair-thin tails and orange spots by the tail | Underside chalky white to pale silvery grey, not slate grey; males bright blue above; the line beneath is broken into spots rather than continuous |
| Green hairstreak, Callophrys rubi | Small hairstreak of similar habitats in Europe | Vivid green underside, no tails, and an Old World range that does not overlap the gray hairstreak at all |
Quick facts
| Scientific name | Strymon melinus Hübner, 1818 |
|---|---|
| Family | Lycaenidae (gossamer-winged butterflies), subfamily Theclinae |
| Other names | Common hairstreak, cotton square borer, bean lycaenid |
| Wingspan | 0.9–1.4 in (22–35 mm) |
| Distribution | Southern Canada through all of the continental United States and Mexico to Central America, Colombia and Venezuela |
| Habitat | Open sunny ground: weedy fields, roadsides, vacant lots, farmland, gardens, prairie and open woodland; up to about 8,000 ft |
| Host plants | Chiefly pea family (beans, clover, alfalfa) and mallow family (cotton, hibiscus, hollyhock), plus dozens of other families |
| Adult food | Nectar from dogbane, milkweed, sweet clover, mints, goldenrod and winter cress; also damp soil |
| Lifespan of adults | About 2–4 weeks |
| Broods | Two in the north, three or four in the south, nearly continuous in Florida and south Texas |
| Overwintering stage | Chrysalis |
| Defense | False head of tails and eyespot; larvae tended by ants; cryptic grey underside |
| Conservation status | Abundant and secure; one of the most widespread butterflies in North America |
Did you know?
- Cotton growers know this butterfly as the cotton square borer, because the caterpillar bores into the unopened flower buds — the "squares" — of a cotton plant. In beans it is called the bean lycaenid. Damage is usually trivial.
- The false-head trick can be measured. Hairstreaks caught in the wild very often show symmetrical beak-shaped bites out of both hindwings, exactly where the decoy sits, which means the strike landed on the wrong end.
- The caterpillar is not really a leaf eater. It starts life inside flower buds and seed pods, and its flattened, woodlouse-like shape is well suited to squeezing into a bud.
- The colour of the caterpillar often follows its food. Larvae on pink clover heads tend to be pink, larvae on green pods green — camouflage that is half accident of diet and half adaptation.
- Ants tending a hairstreak larva are paying for a service. The caterpillar's dorsal gland secretes a sugar-and-amino-acid solution, and in return the ants keep parasitoid wasps away.
- Legumes, mallows, mints, buckwheats, strawberry, hops, oak, corn and okra have all been recorded as food, which is why the species is found almost everywhere in the Americas.
In summary
The gray hairstreak is a small slate-grey butterfly with one thin white-and-black line edged in orange on the underside, a red-orange spot beside a pair of hair-fine tails, and a habit of sawing its hindwings together while perched. It flies in open, weedy, sunny places from southern Canada to Venezuela, in two broods in the north and up to four in the south, and it overwinters as a brown, velvety chrysalis in leaf litter. Its caterpillars bore into the buds and pods of an enormous range of plants, are often escorted by ants, and are among the very few butterfly larvae with a name in a cotton-growing manual.
Gray Hairstreak butterfly pictures


Frequently asked questions about the gray hairstreak butterfly
What do gray hairstreak caterpillars eat?
They eat the flower buds, flowers, seed pods and fruits of a huge range of plants, taking leaves only as they get older. The pea family (beans, clover, alfalfa, lespedeza) and the mallow family (cotton, hibiscus, hollyhock) are the most important, but knotweeds, mints, strawberry, hawthorn, oak, hops and corn are all used.
How can you tell male and female gray hairstreaks apart?
Not easily. The sexes look almost identical, both slate grey above with a red-orange spot near the tail. Females average slightly paler and marginally shorter in the body, and males carry a small oval patch of scent scales on the forewing upperside, but that is visible only in the hand, so field sexing is unreliable.
How long does the gray hairstreak pupa stage last?
About seven to ten days in warm weather. A chrysalis formed late in the season behaves differently: it enters dormancy, passes the whole winter in leaf litter or a crevice, and the adult emerges the following spring. Gray hairstreaks always overwinter as a chrysalis, never as an egg, caterpillar or adult.
What habitat does the gray hairstreak prefer?
Open, sunny, disturbed ground rather than dense vegetation or shade. Weedy fields, roadsides, vacant lots, pastures, farmland, prairie, gardens and open woodland all suit it, from sea level to around 8,000 feet. This flexibility, combined with an enormous host plant list, is why the species is common from Canada to South America.
What does a gray hairstreak pupa look like?
The chrysalis is small, about four tenths of an inch, plump and rounded rather like a shelled peanut. It is mid to dark brown, speckled with darker flecks, and covered in a short velvety pile that helps it blend into soil and leaf litter. It is anchored by a silk pad and a fine silk girdle.
Why does the gray hairstreak have tails on its hindwings?
They are part of a false head. The hair-thin white-tipped tails mimic antennae, the red-and-black spot beside them mimics an eye, and the underside lines converge on the spot as veins would on a real head. Perched butterflies rub the hindwings to make the tails twitch, drawing strikes to the expendable rear of the wing.
Do ants look after gray hairstreak caterpillars?
Often, yes. The caterpillar has a gland on its back that secretes a sugary, amino-acid-rich fluid. Ants feed on it and in return patrol the larva and drive off parasitic wasps and flies. The partnership is optional for both species, but tended caterpillars survive at a noticeably higher rate than untended ones.
Where does the gray hairstreak live?
It has one of the widest ranges of any North American butterfly, from southern British Columbia and the Maritimes south through every one of the lower 48 states, Mexico and Central America to Colombia and Venezuela. It is common throughout that range wherever there is open, sunny, weedy ground with flowers.
Is the gray hairstreak a pest?
Only marginally. Because the caterpillars bore into cotton flower buds, known as squares, and into bean pods, the species has the farm names cotton square borer and bean lycaenid. In practice numbers almost never reach damaging levels, and the adults are useful pollinators of small-flowered plants.
How can you tell a gray hairstreak from a red-banded hairstreak?
Look at the line across the underside. The gray hairstreak has a thin white-and-black postmedian line with an orange border on the inner side, on a plain slate-grey ground. The red-banded hairstreak has a wide red-orange band instead, shows more blue on the hindwing upperside, and is noticeably smaller.
